Winter 2018

Why Humanitarian Aid Matters

3 questions with Gregory Gottlieb.

By Julie Flaherty

Previous Next

Gregory Gottlieb is the new director of the Feinstein International Center. Photo: Anna Miller

President Donald Trump’s 2018 budget proposal includes steep cuts to the State Department, the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), and the United Nations. That policy change could have lasting impact on humanitarian efforts worldwide, said Gregory Gottlieb, Irwin H. Rosenberg Professor in Nutrition and Human Security and the new director of the Feinstein International Center at the Friedman School. We spoke with Gottlieb, who was the acting assistant administrator for USAID’s Bureau for Democracy, Conflict, and Humanitarian Assistance before coming to Tufts, about the challenges ahead.

Tufts Nutrition: How does an America First policy affect humanitarianism?

Gregory Gottlieb: The United States has really helped to build the international system of humanitarian relief. We have been the biggest giver, the donor of last resort in many respects. And if you want to change that, you don’t do it by saying we’re going to cut our budget by 40 percent overnight. That is just going to damage the system. You can’t just cut our budget and hope that other nations step in to make up the difference.

TN: How do the United States’ humanitarian efforts help improve its standing in the world?

GG: Soft power like humanitarian aid can be very beneficial and serve as a tool for political advantages. After the tsunami in Asia in 2004, the fact that we supplied humanitarian assistance allowed our military to collaborate with Indonesia’s military. If you looked at how people there viewed the United States, our ratings went way up. The same in Pakistan after the 2005 earthquake. Some of the people who did that work are still incredibly well thought of. In South Sudan, our humanitarian assistance opened up a better dialogue between Sudan and South Sudan, as they were forced to negotiate about how to move food across the lines.But humanitarian assistance is not the answer in and of itself. Without political will, it doesn’t matter how much assistance you provide; it is not going to lead to a solution. There is a lot of aid going to Yemen, but it is not leading to any discussion whatsoever.

TN: What is going to be the bigger challenge for humanitarianism: natural disasters from climate change or crises stemming from conflict?

GG: The U.S. government spends 80 percent of its humanitarian money right now on conflicts, and they go on year after year after year. Yemen, Syria, Nigeria, South Sudan—you can hope that we attain world peace, but I’m going to guess that’s not going to happen any time soon. In that case, needs will remain high. In terms of climate, if we get more natural disasters, if we get hurricanes with the frequency that we have been, then we just have to be prepared. You have to train your rescue people. You can build in ways that make your buildings more durable. I think Bangladesh is one of the best examples of how investing in preparedness can save lives. When a typhoon hit in 1991, about 150,000 people died. Now there are better warning systems. There are concrete shelters on higher ground, and they train kids in school about getting to them. In the last typhoon, far fewer people died. The question is, when we look at our humanitarian budget, are we prepared to put more money into preparedness?

Top Stories

Tufts Nutrition Top 10

How climate change will affect agriculture and nutrition.

Remaking Main Streets

Working in three very different places, certificate graduates are finding smart ways to make their communities healthier.

Counter Culture

American families are eating out more than ever, but aren’t always making the healthiest choices. Tufts researchers are working with restaurants and parents to change that.

Called to Serve

They wanted to do something good for the world. It became the foundation for a career.

Editor's Picks

Gut Reaction

Can what you eat change your gut microbiome?

Paying Bonuses to Improve Nutrition

Can a strategy from the business world help solve public health problems?

Spending Smarter

Teaching kids to make better snack choices with their own pocket money.

Brain Health Breakthrough

A common infection is linked to Alzheimer's and other neurodegenerative diseases.