Science and the Shutdown

Beyond the people and research directly impacted by the partial government shutdown, there are additional stories regarding the impact of this shutdown that should also be told. From my own discussions with friends and family it’s clear that there is a substantial under appreciation for how many additional people and programs are being affected by this. Work on this project, being one example.

Not along ago, seals were essentially extinct within the US waters of the North Atlantic. Born in the mid 70s, I grew up in New England and never once heard anything to suggest that I lived in a region that large marine mammals also called home. After the marine mammal protection act went into effect in 1972, it took 20-30 years before the population rebounded enough to become noticeable to those frequenting the Atlantic coast. Until recently it was a fairly rare event to see a seal along the Cape. In the last decade, the local population has undergone such rapid growth that seals have thrust themselves into heated public controversies that span fisheries, tourism, recreation, conservation, public health, and public safety. As this large, long lived species recolonizes an area that is densely populated by humans, in a region rapidly feeling the impact of a changing climate and shifting ecosystems, a wide range of critical questions NEED answers.

This past summer, an unusually high number of seals showed up on the beaches of New England dead or dieing at least in part, from a viral infection; animal provisioning led to the inevitable assertiveness of a wild animal looking for a hand out and resulted in two people being bitten by seals off of Cape Cod; and a life was tragically lost to a shark attack for the first time in 82 years, leading to an outcry for a cull on seals.

And yet this year, we will have little to no data that can be used to help inform the way forward. The government shutdown has prevented NOAA from conducting their work on population numbers, has prevented us from conducting our work on infectious disease, has prevented deployment of satellite tags that would enable tracking animal movements to better understand haul out usage and fishing grounds, and has prevented collection of data on diet, health, and contaminant loads.

Although many of us contributing to this work come from academic institutions or nonprofit organizations and our jobs are not technically shutdown, we rely upon expertise and resources of those who are.

And therefore, our work is shutdown.

Work that we do not simply pick back up when the government decides to reopen. The pupping season will be over. Our access to the animals will be gone. This entire research season, a critical season, will forever be missing from the dataset. And come next summer when we are faced with continuing challenges associated with increasing human/animal interactions, we will be missing some of the critical data that is needed to make effective, informed, decisions.

1 thought on “Science and the Shutdown

  1. The work that you all do is so important. Thank you for all that you do! Here’s to hoping our ‘elected leaders’ can act like grown ups and come up with a compromise soon to get everyone back to work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.