The City of Boston’s official website reports that TOTAL greenhouse gas emissions are 5.4 million metric tons of CO2e, but this is misleading, because it excludes aviation and Logan Airport.
Separately, Logan Airport reports aviation emissions of 0.5 million metric tons of CO2e, but this is misleading, because it counts only emissions up to 3000 feet of altitude (essentially counting emissions only for takeoff and landing but not the majority of the flight in between).
The true Logan Airport emissions for aviation, based on jet fuel sales, are 4.3 million metric tons of CO2e, which is much larger relative to total Boston emissions than most people realize.
Tufts University #flyingless video and article. The Tufts University media site Tufts Now has given our #flyingless initiative some energetic coverage, including a video, feature article, interactive map, and chart comparing transportation modes. Consider sharing the link above with your own social media networks. Or you may forward it by email within your own university to ask, “could our university promote the climate action efforts of our own faculty in similar fashion?”
Gianluca takes a stand. Our friend and long-time #flyingless supporter, Prof. Gianluca Grimalda is returning home by ship, train, and bus to Germany from his anthropology field research site in the Solomon Islands, at the cost of his faculty position at the Kiel Institute, which is firing him for being late returning to the office this fall. His act of principle received extensive media coverage in the Guardian, New York Times, CNN, and many other outlets. Don’t ask whether we each can do likewise (that would be a lot to ask). But we can each reflect on Gianluca’s courage as a mark of what is possible, as we take stock of what perhaps more modest collective action is possible within our own university communities.
New Years’ Eve Eve Party (Dec 30). We usually host an online social event with toasts and reflections on #flyingless themes each December 30, at 4pm eastern (9pm UK, 10pm CET). Please hold the date. If you are tempted to host and log in from a local party in your own community at that time, please contact us by email. We’d love to coordinate.
We love traveling by train. Personally, I like the views, comfort, station architecture and locations, connection to history, suitability for laptop work, and people. And, in a time of climate emergency, traveling by train offers a sense of having one foot in the world that is and another foot in the world that ought to be.
A couple weeks ago, while traveling by Amtrak from Boston to Kansas City, I had a video conversation with Prof. Adam Aron of the University of California San Diego, who was coincidentally traveling the same route in the opposite direction on his way to the East Coast for speaking events related to his wonderful new book, The Climate Crisis. This week, I saw on social media that climate scientist and #flyingless supporter Milan Klöwer, along with climate scientist Viktoria Cologna, are right now on their way across the country to California.
So it seems like a good time to collect information and reflections on long-distance train travel for professionals in the United States. Jeb Brooks has a nice YouTube video embedded below, with a well-organized summary of detailed strengths and limitations of travel different options, from coach to roomette to bedroom. Here are my own additional comments and tips, in more random order.
Enjoy meeting people from different walks of life and regions of the country. Even recognizing the growth of budget flying in recent decades, trains seem still more diverse by economics, race, ethnicity, and lifestyle than planes. For example, Amtrak’s Lakeshore Limited, which I travel frequently, is bustling with Amish families. If you like conversation, trains are more social than planes.
For work on laptops and cell phone, download some files in advance to smoothly adapt to gaps in internet. Be prepared to switch occasionally from cell phone hotspot to Amtrak WiFi, depending on which seems to work best at a particular time.
For the best price, choose coach. The prices are competitive with flying. If you travel overnight in coach, bring an eye mask for sleeping, fleece or comfortable jacket, and neck-supporting pillow. For best comfort, choose a roomette. The food comes free and there is a private toilet and a shower down the hall. Personally, I choose coach for overnight travel if I will have an opportunity to rest up afterwards, but I’ll splurge for a roomette if I have professional meetings the next day or if I have been on the road for multiple days.
Bring fresh fruit and some healthy food. The cafe car offers adequate but highly processed food and beverages.
For physical comfort, avoidance of back pain, and to reduce a small risk of blood circulation health hazard from sitting too long, be sure to walk around and stretch frequently. Get nice outdoor time every time the public address announces a “smoking break” (ha). But do stay close to the door to avoid missing a train. (I am too chagrined to explain how this lesson was learned, once long ago). Take advantage of this key advantage of trains over planes.
Be philosophical about train delays. Amtrak is usually but not always on time in the Northeast Corridor. In other regions of the country, delays of a couple hours are common and delays of several hours are possible. You might think it excessive, but I plan for a 2+ hour gap before my first meeting in the northeast and a 6+ hour or overnight gap outside of the northeast.
Enjoy the low-carbon travel. Most Amtrak trips are in the northeast, where trains run many times daily and are electric, with carbon emissions far lower than flying. Elsewhere in the country, trains typically run once daily and are diesel-powered, with carbon emissions that are still somewhat lower than flying. In a spirit of “skating to where the puck will be,” I am happy to contribute economic demand to the train market, even while advocating for electrification elsewhere.
Amtrak workers are lovely people, more blunt and sharp-worded than I recall being typical in air travel. They can be more bossy than people in other service sectors such as restaurants. I don’t mind. Amtrak workers are unionized, and Amtrak is not in a competitive market. For me, personally, the non-deferential style has an egalitarian spirit. Trains reflect the world I want to live in.